Pumpkin Cream Pie Recipe – Gemma’s Larger Bolder Baking

This put up could include affiliate hyperlinks. Please see my full disclosure for particulars.

Hello Daring Bakers!

WHY YOU’LL LOVE THIS RECIPE: Our Pumpkin Cream Pie Recipe is a creamier, silkier various to standard pumpkin pie. It’s the entire seasonal pumpkin spice yumminess with a decidedly extra elegant twist. Our super-simple Graham cracker crumb crust provides a delightful, salty-sweet, crunchy distinction to the whipped filling.

• No-bake ease! You received’t take up oven house with this creamy pumpkin pie recipe. The crust is no-bake; you prepare dinner the filling on the stovetop.
• Make-ahead pie: This pie takes solely half-hour to arrange, then pop it within the fridge to relax in a single day. This can be a big bonus if you’re internet hosting vacation dinners!
• Delectably tender and velvety: In case you’re a pumpkin lover however aren’t a fan of the everyday dense (typically rubbery!) pumpkin pie, this whipped, gentle Pumpkin Cream Pie is what you’ve been dreaming of.
• Completely pumpkiny! This recipe has the best complement of spices that don’t overwhelm the gorgeous pumpkin taste.

Rising up in Eire, I didn’t have many pumpkin desserts, however after shifting to California, I completely fell in love with all issues pumpkin. Search “pumpkin” on BiggerBolderBaking, and also you’ll see that I’ve made up for misplaced time! Dive into pumpkin spice taste with Pumpkin Cinnamon Rolls with Pumpkin Butter, Selfmade Pumpkin Spice Espresso Creamer, Crock Pot Pumpkin Cobbler, and Gemma’s Finest Ever Pumpkin Bread.

Desk of Contents

What’s Pumpkin Cream Pie?

• Pumpkin Cream Pie is a no-bake pumpkin pie made with a cookie crust. It’s stuffed with spiced pumpkin custard, and the pie is chilled earlier than serving.
• Our Pumpkin Cream Pie is lighter and creamier than conventional pumpkin pie. In our recipe, the pumpkin custard is with egg yolks, whipping cream, milk, and pumpkin as an alternative of the everyday evaporated milk and entire eggs. This ends in a easy, velvety, pudding-like texture that isn’t as thick and stable as customary pumpkin pie.
• Pumpkins have been a staple in Native Individuals’ diets. They launched the vegetable to colonial settlers, and a recipe for pumpkin pie first appeared in 1796 within the guide American Cookery by Amelia Simmons. Through the years, the colourful pie turned a staple at Thanksgiving dinner. When Libby’s started to can pumpkin within the early twentieth century, the pie turned simpler to make and a perennial favourite!

Key Substances and Why

1 Cookie Crust

• Offers a crumbly, buttery base fir the pie. 

Darkish brown sugar

• Darkish brown sugar offers the filling a heat molasses sweetness.
• It’s greatest to make use of darkish brown sugar right here as its molasses content material is twice as a lot as gentle brown sugar, giving it a bolder taste.
• Discover ways to make your individual brown sugar, and methods to make your gentle brown sugar into darkish brown sugar.

Corn starch

• Cornstarch thickens the filling by absorbing the surplus liquid and helps type a steady construction.

Pumpkin pie spice, cinnamon, and ginger

• Pumpkin pie spice (cinnamon, ginger, allspice, nutmeg, and cloves) add zippy, fragrant notes which might be the essence of fall. You may as well use blends referred to as “apple pie spice” and “blended spice.”
• A small extra quantity of ginger and cinnamon bumps up the heat.
• For probably the most impactful taste, be certain that your spices are recent!

Salt

• Salt enhances the entire flavors and balances out the sweetness.

Egg yolks

• The egg yolks mix the components collectively, making a persistently easy pumpkin cream texture.
• Egg yolks give the custard a velvety mouthfeel and wealthy taste.
• Throughout cooking, the egg yolks coagulate to thicken the filling.

Entire milk

• Entire milk offers the pumpkin custard an exquisite creaminess and silkiness.
• It’s vital to make use of entire milk with heavy cream on this recipe, because it lightens the filling, so it’s lush however not dense.

Heavy whipping cream

• Heavy whipping cream, with a 36% fats content material, makes this filling amazingly thick and billowy.
• Cream’s pure dairy sugars contribute to the flavour, with freshness that develops caramelly notes throughout cooking.

Pumpkin purée

• Canned pumpkin purée offers the pie pure pumpkin taste and a easy texture.
• Alternatively, you should utilize candy potato or butternut squash puree. You may as well simply make your individual Selfmade Pumpkin Purée!

Butter

• Butter retains moisture, helps bind the filling, and contributes to the sleek texture.
• Importantly, butter provides wealthy salty-sweet taste and develops toasty notes by cooking.

Vanilla extract

• Vanilla’s warmly candy, floral, subtly spicy notes complement the pumpkin and spice flavors.

Methods to Make Pumpkin Cream Pie

Put together

1. Line the underside and sides of a 9-inch (23 cm) pie pan with the cookie crust and refrigerate when you put together the filling.

Make the pumpkin filling

2. Place a heatproof bowl with a superb mesh sieve on prime of it subsequent to the range.
3. In a medium saucpan, whisk collectively the brown sugar, cornstarch, pie spice, cinnamon, salt and ginger.

4. Stir the egg yolks, milk, and cream collectively in a medium bowl, then pour into the dry components and whisk to mix.

5. Prepare dinner the combination over medium warmth, whisking continually till thickened and effervescent.

6. Preserve cooking for two full minutes whereas it bubbles, stirring continually, to totally activate the cornstarch.

7. Instantly pour the filling by the sieve to cease the cooking and catch any solids.

Assemble the pie and chill

9. Clean the highest and return to the fridge to totally chill for a minimum of 3 hours and as much as in a single day.

10. Simply earlier than serving, garnish with a beneficiant quantity of freshly whipped cream.

Gemma’s Professional Chef Suggestions

• The no-bake cookie crust is sort of delicate. If you want one thing a bit firmer, bake the crust (with out the filling) at 350°F (180°C) for 10 minutes. Let cool fully earlier than filling.
• This filling is frivolously spiced, which we like for this pie. Make sure you style it earlier than filling your pie, and bump up the spices if you’d like.
• As a substitute of creating a pie, you possibly can chill the filling in small cups to make particular person puddings.
• Use Graham crackers, vanilla biscuits, and even gingersnap biscuits to essentially praise the spiced pumpkin filling.

Make Forward and Storage Directions

• Make forward directions:
  • If you want to make this pumpkin spice cream pie as much as two days forward of time, freeze the Graham cracker crust till agency, then brush with a bit melted white or darkish chocolate.
  • Let this harden after which let the filling cool to room temperature earlier than spreading it into the crust. The chocolate will forestall the moisture within the filling from making the crust soggy.
• Methods to retailer leftovers:
  • Cowl leftover pumpkin cream pie loosely with plastic wrap and retailer within the fridge for as much as two days.

FAQs

How do I be certain that my filling is easy and creamy?

• Your egg yolks needs to be at room temperature, and including chilly egg yolks may curdle curdling.
• Make sure you sieve the filling if you wish to make sure that it’s further easy.

Can I exploit recent pumpkin on this pie?

• Sure, you possibly can roast and puree your individual pumpkin or different squash as an alternative of canned puree. Each butternut and orange kabocha squash would make scrumptious fillings.
• You may as well make a batch of your individual pumpkin purée and freeze the leftovers to make use of in different pumpkin recipes.
• Don’t use canned pumpkin pie filling on this recipe, because it incorporates different components moreover pumpkin. As a substitute, purchase pure pumpkin purée.

Can I make this pie with out eggs?

• Egg yolks are a key ingredient on this pie, and egg substitutes wouldn’t provide you with a passable consequence.

Extra Custard and Cream Pie Recipes

Attempt These Recipes!